|
|
|
|
National Trust: failure to enforce ban emboldening huntsCharity banned 'trail hunting' on its land but has failed to take action against hunts
The National Trust (NT) banned so-called trail hunting back in October 2021, after a hard-fought battle by members and campaigners who took a motion to the Trust's AGM in Harrogate. But more than three years later hunts continue to trespass on its estates. Protect the Wild takes a look at the charity's inaction as wildlife continues to be hunted and killed on its land.Hunts need land to hunt on, and the NT is one of the UK's largest landowners. It owns 620,000 acres of land, as well as 780 miles of coast. It's also one of the UK's most popular charities with more than 5.73 million members. In its 2023 annual report, the charity stated that it earned:
It has the influence, weight and funds to enforce its own ban. There is simply no excuse for it not following its members' and donors' wishes. After all, these precious members can always revoke their membership, and donors can give their money to other causes. Let's look at some of the hunts, their actions on NT land, and the charity's response (or lack of) to illegal hunting. The Wynnstay trespasses on Erdigg EstateThe Wynnstay Hunt - whose ex-huntsman was recently convicted of illegal hunting - has been blatantly ignoring the NT ban since it was put in place. And now hunt monitors have captured footage showing the hunt actually riding out of an estate through the NT's own gates. So what action is the landowner taking? On 14 January 2024, Cheshire Borderland Monitorsit captured damning video at the Erddig estate, near Wrexham in north Wales. The monitors have known that the hunt has continued to use National Trust land since the 2021 trail hunting ban came in, but this recent footage - of riders, horses and hounds leaving through the estate gates - surely means that the NT now needs to take firm action. The Wynnstay Hunt is videoed coming out of the National Trust's Erddig Estate gates. Video still via Cheshire Borderland MonitorsProtect the Wild contacted the National Trust to ask the charity whether it is taking any action against the Wynnstay Hunt for trespassing on its Erddig Estate. It gave the same vague response familiar from accusations several years ago that the Trust was ignoring the issue and using a 'bot' to answer similar questions posted on social media:
We replied to the Trust, asking it why it won't publicly clarify the steps it takes to enforce its trail hunting ban. The Trust replied:
We emailed the Trust again with further questions, but it wouldn't give us any more information. So we emailed North Wales Police. The force didn't say that the NT had reported the incident to the force, but that:
It continued:
When pressed more, the police forced confirmed:
North Wales Police also stated to Protect the Wild:
So the landowner avoids taking action by referring to 'illegal activity' and pointing the public to the police - who in turn confirm that they deal only with criminal matters and do not act in civil matters like trespass. It will all be music to the Hunt's ears. Frustrating as it maybe the police are correct of course. The footage does not show illegal hunting. But the Trust could still act. As Cheshire Borderland Monitors point out:
Meanwhile, in a further muddying of the waters, the monitors were told by the Erddig Estate's manager that the Trust is, indeed, liaising with the police about this particular trespass - at least at a local level. It is unclear to Protect the Wild why we are receiving contradictory information, and why the national NT office states that it is "not able to comment on the outcome of any reported incidents". As a charity with almost 6 million members and a landowner that looks after swathes of the UK on behalf of the nation, we argue that it has a duty to be transparent. Quantock StaghoundsIt's not just the Wynnstay that illegally hunts on NT land. The Quantock Staghounds (QSH) is one of England's most brutal hunts and has been killing stags and hinds in the southwest of England for years. The NT Ruling Council banned the QSH from hunting on their land back in 1997, more than twenty years before it outlawed all trail hunting. Despite this, the QSH has continued to trespass over the charity's estates, while the NT has taken absolutely no action. Protect the Wild spoke to Bobbie Armstrong of Somerset Wildlife Crime, a group that has spent years tackling the QSH. Armstrong told us:
Armstrong continued:
However in 2019, the QSH did find itself in court for illegally hunting stags on NT land at Trendle Ring. Video evidence collected by monitors was shown in the court, and in his summing up the magistrate stated that he was in no doubt that a stag was being hunted illegally. But the case failed on a technicality. Armstrong said of this case:
In 2022, Stop Hunting On The Nation's Land - which highlights hunting on public land - also spoke out strongly, outlining links between the NT's own staff and hunting:
Other huntsThe Wynnstay and the Quantock Staghounds are not the only hunts to deliberately trespass on NT land and get away with it. In 2024 alone, hunt saboteurs have reported these incidents:
Tenant farmers on NT property are often hunt supporters, and facilitate illegal hunting on their land. At the end of 2023, Cumbria Hunt Sabs wrote a report, saying:
Photo by Jeremy Vessey on Unsplash The National Trust can, and should, actIn 2018, Mark Harold, the now retired NT's former Director for the South West, was asked at the charity's AGM what the organisation was doing to prevent stag hunting on its land. Harold responded:
But Protect the Wild argues that this is not the best that the NT can do at all. The Trust might claim that it is 'difficult' to prove whether hunts are trespassing on its land, but hunt monitors and saboteurs have more than enough photo and video evidence and have repeatedly said they would make that evidence available - IF the Trust seemed likely to act on it. These monitors are doing the job that the Trust itself should be doing. What could the National Trust do?At its AGM in November last year five candidates for the NT Council from the right-leaning and 'anti woke' Restore Trust who were all endorsed by the pro-hunt Countryside Alliance were rejected by members. There is no interest in repealing the ban on so-called 'trail hunting'. Financial resources aren't a barrier either. The NT was proud to announce that it received a record level of income in 2022/23. It undoubtedly has the mandate and the funds to take robust action to enforce their own 'trail hunting' ban. Actions could range from the extremely simple to the more complex and could entail:
On that last point, Cheshire Borderland Monitors told us:
Meanwhile, Armstrong argues that if the NT were to actually act against illegal hunting, it could help bring an end to the brutality and cruelty of deer hunting. She said:
And Cumbria Hunt Sabs have stated:
Help us support activists on the ground!Our content is free but if you choose to take out a paid subscription you’ll be helping activists on the ground take direct action to protect wildlife. Every penny we receive tops up our Equipment Fund to support those in the field. We currently have an amazing 641 of you on paid subscriptions helping fund the above, can you help us reach our next milestone?
© 2024 Protect the Wild |