Wednesday, 18 November 2026

ANOTHER ONE ON WELSH BADGERS. SCIENCE OF THE NEED NOT REALLY KNOWN

Forwarded this email? Subscribe here for more This time next week, Wales is likely to announce a badger cull This is an emergency. Please take action ELIZA EGRET NOV 17 READ IN APP On 24 November, the Welsh Government is likely to announce whether it will cull badgers in its efforts to tackle bovine TB. Yet its decision is being made against a backdrop of serious unanswered scientific questions, inadequate public scrutiny and a failure to give the people of Wales a meaningful opportunity to have their say. This is not an acceptable way to make a decision that could result in thousands of protected wild animals being killed. Email the minister now Plaid Cymru is spearheading these plans, which mirror England’s failed Tory policy brought in by David Cameron. Having won over voters on a progressive, green platform, Plaid now risks betraying that mandate and losing the support it only recently gained. Under previous Welsh Labour governments, Wales slashed bovine TB without an England-style badger cull, proving that slaughtering wildlife is unnecessary to protect farmed cows. With the vast majority of herds already TB-free, better testing, movement controls, and biosecurity offer far stronger disease control than scapegoating wildlife. Yet under Plaid Cymru, the government’s stance on bovine TB looks less like science-led policy and more like capitulation to the farming lobby. Following the science…? The Welsh Government has repeatedly stated that its approach to bovine TB will be science-led. Despite claiming this, Plaid voted in favour of a Senedd motion backing a targeted cull before even receiving recommendations from its Technical Advisory Group. Now, it looks likely that Minister Llŷr Gruffydd will make his announcement on a cull without allowing independent or public scrutiny of the scientific ‘evidence’ behind the decision. It is not enough to simply tell the public that a policy is evidence-based. The evidence itself, and the process used to assess it, must be open to scrutiny. Stop the rushed badger cull Take action Please use our quick tool to send a direct message to Gruffydd. Within seconds, you can demand that he takes these actions: Delay the proposed 24 November announcement of any decision to introduce or expand badger culling. Commit to a full public consultation before any final decision, with an explicit option to reject badger culling altogether and continue with non-lethal, cattle-focused disease control. Publish the full scientific advice and recommendations informing the Government’s position, including the Technical Advisory Group’s advice, the Bovine TB Eradication Programme Board’s recommendations and the evidence underpinning any proposed wildlife intervention, in sufficient time for meaningful public scrutiny. Facilitate proper independent scientific scrutiny, including a proposed workshop involving scientists Professor Paul Torgerson, Tom Langton and other appropriately qualified experts, so that competing scientific evidence and unresolved questions can be properly examined. Allow the Senedd to hold a full debate before any final policy decision is made, giving elected representatives the opportunity to scrutinise the evidence and represent the concerns of their constituents. Demonstrate how any proposed intervention would meet Wales’s legal environmental and biodiversity responsibilities. Section 6C(2) of the Environment (Wales) Act 2016 sets out the statutory priority areas for biodiversity targets, starting with “(a) reducing the risk of the extinction of native species.” It would be an extraordinary contradiction for a government that speaks about protecting nature and reversing biodiversity loss to introduce the widespread killing of a protected native mammal without first demonstrating that it is necessary and effective. The Welsh government must not push this decision through first and ask the public afterwards. It must rule out badger culling unless it is justified through a transparent and lawful process. The people and wildlife of Cymru deserve nothing less. Have your say in 60 seconds We’ve been working incredibly hard behind the scenes on WILD, our brand new quarterly print magazine, and I’d absolutely love for you to give our very first edition a go! It’s packed with investigative journalism, incredible wildlife photography, fascinating interviews and stories about what’s really happening to animals across Britain. GET WILD MAGAZINE You can get our very first edition from just £6 with no subscription needed :) Every purchase helps bring future editions to life, funding more investigations, exposing cruelty and telling the stories of animals whose suffering too often goes unheard. SHARE LIKE COMMENT RESTACK © 2026 Protect the Wild Protect the Wild, 71-75 Shelton Street Covent Garden, London, W2CH 9JQ Unsubscribe Start your Substack

No comments:

Post a Comment